Sutter,5
David had two marriages which also shaped his life. One was to the beautiful yet
immature Dora Spenlow. Dora is young, small and angelic. She is also cheerful but helpless. She
has a weak personality as she cannot keep a house and certainly cannot survive childbirth. On the
other hand, Agnes is wise unlike Dora who is ignorant. She is serious and wins David trust. The
two women contributed to fulfilling David needs. Dora was unable to keep up a house even with
the help of David as she could not understand simple chores. We see that one day Dora asked
David to explain to her on how to do house-keeping which David did willingly but later we see
Dora breaking down and crying as she could not comprehend anything. The attraction that David
had towards Dora was her beauty which misleads him into marrying her. Although Dora is
portrayed as a character that lacks insight, at the end of the story we see that she realizes that her
marriage to David was a mistake and her immaturity would make David lose his love towards
her as she explains that “as years went on, my dear boy would have wearied of his child- wife.
She would have been less and less a companion for him. He would have been more and more
sensible of what wanted in his home. She wouldn't have improved”. (p, 711). The death of Dora
during childbirth gave David to choose a wife more wisely. Dora makes David life hard as he is
always stepping up to take care of the house as Dora is incapable. She makes David understand
that marriage is more than a beautiful woman.
On the other hand, Agnes was a very intelligent person who was also close to David as
she was his confidant. In the book, David at times consider her as his sister as he once lived
under her roof and came to like her very much. David was attracted to Agnes personality as she
was kind and simple unlike in the case of Dora where he was attracted to her beauty but still it
takes a lot of time for David to realize Agnes was the one for him and marry her which is well
explained by his own words “I see her, with her modest, orderly, placid manner, and I hear her